Identity Crisis | Week 5 | Bill Bush · Rewind

Identity Crisis | Week 5 | Bill Bush · Rewind

Pastor Bill Bush · May 22, 2022

Big Idea

A recovered identity redeems your past — you don't discover who you are, you recover it in Christ, and that means getting past your past instead of staying stuck in it.

Your past — the hurts done to you, the pain you've endured, the sins you've committed — does not have to define who you are. In Christ you can release resentment, let God repurpose your pain, and remember the cross instead of drowning in guilt, so your identity is found in Him, not in what happened to you.

Key points

1
1We don't discover our identity, we recover it — it's rooted in either Adam or Christ.
Pastor Bill frames this as the final message in a series on identity. Every person was made in God's image to be a mirror reflecting His attributes, but the fall fractured that relationship. Now every person's identity is either found in the broken, created things of this world (the way of Adam) or recovered through Christ.
2
2If you can't get past your past, it will paralyze your present and steal your future.
Drawing from Paul's words in Philippians, Pastor Bill notes Paul had done horrible things and suffered greatly, yet learned to forget what was behind and press toward what God made him to be. He names three ways people stay stuck: rehearsing resentments, being paralyzed by pain, and reinforcing remorse.
3
3Release your resentments through forgiveness, but understand forgiveness is not the same as reconciliation.
Using Ephesians 4:31-32, he explains that bitterness has to be replaced with kindness and forgiveness, not just wished away. He clarifies that reconciliation takes two people and requires trust to be rebuilt, but forgiveness only takes one — so you can forgive someone and still choose not to reengage with them. He shares personally writing down a hurt and burning it as an act of forgiveness.
4
4Let God repurpose your pain instead of staying paralyzed by it.
From 2 Corinthians 1, he shows that God comforts us in our troubles so we can comfort others with that same comfort — healing comes through using the pain, not avoiding it. He illustrates this with his friend Malenga's story of being wrongfully imprisoned for two years in a Tanzanian prison, where he led inmates to Christ and later used his testimony to see hundreds respond to the gospel.
5
5Remember the cross instead of reinforcing remorse over your own sin and guilt.
Walking through Luke 22 and the Last Supper, he contrasts Judas, who felt remorse but never returned to confess and ended in self-destruction, with Peter, who also betrayed Jesus but came back and confessed. He warns that self-condemnation leads either to death or to denying guilt altogether, but remembering the cross and surrendering is the way back.

Application

Pastor Bill's charge is to deal with your past instead of letting it become who you are: release your resentments, let God repurpose your pain, and remember the cross.

Release your resentments through forgiveness
If you're carrying anger toward someone who hurt you, choose to forgive them, even if it doesn't mean reconciling. Consider a practical step like writing it down and letting it go, or checking out Celebrate Recovery on Friday nights.
Let God repurpose your pain
Instead of staying paralyzed by grief or loss, surrender it to God and look for ways to use it to comfort others, following the model of Malenga's story. Grief Share is offered for those needing support in this.
Remember the cross instead of self-condemning
When guilt over your own failures rises, don't reinforce it or numb it — return to Jesus like Peter did rather than running from Him like Judas. Confess and receive His forgiveness rather than trying to fix yourself.
Surrender your life to Jesus at the cross
For anyone who has never trusted Christ, confess your sin and put your faith in Him now, praying to receive Him as Lord and Savior before taking communion.

Take it into your week

Sign in to ask Rewind about this sermon

7-day devotional

A personal reading plan from this message — scripture, reflection, and prayer for each day.

Sign in to track your progress through this devotional.

Day 1

Paul writes from a prison cell — not exactly a place of comfort — and says he has learned to do one thing: forget what is behind and press toward what is ahead. That word 'forget' doesn't mean pretend it never happened. Paul knew his past well. He had overseen the murder of Christians. He carried that. But he refused to let it set the course. He pressed forward. Pastor Bill opened the sermon by naming something most of us know firsthand: the past has a way of becoming louder than the present. We rehearse old hurts. We replay old failures. We let those replays slowly become a story we tell about who we are. But Paul's language here is active — straining forward, pressing on. Recovery of identity isn't passive. It isn't waiting until you feel better or until the memories fade. It is a daily, deliberate choice to stop letting yesterday write tomorrow's headline. This week, that's the invitation sitting in front of you. Not to have it all figured out by Friday, but simply to name what's pulling you backward and to begin — just begin — turning your face toward the cross instead.

For reflection

What specific memory, failure, or hurt do you find yourself mentally rehearsing most often, and what would it mean to stop letting that define your story?

Pray

Pray for the willingness to loosen your grip on the past and take one step forward today.

Small-group discussion guide

For leading a group conversation about this message.

Open

This message centers on a simple but disorienting idea: the past we keep rehearsing can quietly become the identity we live from — and Pastor Bill argues the Bible has a different starting point entirely.

Discussion questions

1
In Philippians 3:12–14, Paul describes himself as 'pressing on' and 'forgetting what is behind.' What do you think Paul means by 'forgetting' — is he saying the past didn't happen, or something else?
2
Pastor Bill drew a distinction between forgiveness and reconciliation — that it takes two people to reconcile but only one to forgive. Looking at Ephesians 4:31–32, how does that distinction change the way we might read Paul's call to 'forgive one another'?
3
In 2 Corinthians 1:4–5, Paul says God comforts us in our troubles so that we can comfort others with the same comfort we've received. What do you think that 'passing it on' dynamic looks like in real community?
4
Pastor Bill contrasted Peter and Judas — both failed Jesus badly, but one returned to the cross and was restored while the other turned inward and was destroyed. From what Luke 22 shows us about Peter, what do you think made the difference for him?
5
Pastor Bill said our identity isn't something we discover by wandering through life's options — it's something we recover by returning to the cross. How does framing identity as 'recovery' rather than 'discovery' change the way people might think about who they are?
6
Pastor Bill pointed to Celebrate Recovery and to sharing your story in community as concrete ways to stop going it alone with resentment, pain, or guilt. What makes it hard for people to take a step like that — and what might make it feel more possible?

Pray together

Freedom from a past that has become a false identity — and the courage to come back to the cross

Sign in to save this message.

Topics

Forgiveness and Reconciliation Grace and Redemption Identity in Christ Overcoming the Past Pain and Suffering

Powered by Rewind · make your church's Rewind →