Skip to main content

Ask Rewind

Sign in to ask Rewind about this sermon — answers are grounded in the actual transcripts.

The study, discipleship, and teaching platform built on your church's own preaching.

Product

How it works
Pricing
What's new
Churches on Rewind

Solutions

For churches
For teaching teams
For groups
For seminaries
Agency partners

Company

About
Contact

Legal

Trust & your data
Terms
Privacy
How we use AI
Accessibility

© 2026 Rewind

Evidence of Eternity | Week 2 | Message · Rewind

Rock Point Church

51 min

Pastor Bill Bush · Aug 4, 2025 · 4 min read · 51 min listen

The big idea

Quoting the message: Reason says risen, end quote. — the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus stands up like a case in court, and it points to a verdict of faith, not blind belief.

In this message

The big idea
Point 1 of 5Exhibit A: The empty tomb is a historically proven fact.
Point 2 of 5Exhibit B: The early creed and eyewitness testimony show this wasn't a slowly-grown legend.

Point 3 of 5Exhibit C: The disciples were transformed in ways a lie could never produce.
Point 4 of 5Exhibit D: The explosion of the church in the very city that opposed it.
Point 5 of 5Exhibit E: Hundreds of fulfilled prophecies written centuries before Jesus.
Take it into your week
Transcript

Ask Rewind about this message

Sign in to ask Rewind about this message

Scripture in this message

1 Corinthians 15
1 Corinthians 15:17
Matthew 28:6
Matthew 28
1 Corinthians 15:3
Psalm 16:10

Rewind AI drafted the Big Idea and some point headings shown here from the sermon transcript. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI

Pastor Bill Bush · Aug 4, 2025 · 51 min watch · 2 min read

Evidence of Eternity | Week 2 | Message

In this message

Big Idea
Key points
Application

Scripture in this message

1 Corinthians 15
1 Corinthians 15:17
Matthew 28:6
Matthew 28
1 Corinthians 15:3
Psalm 16:10

Big Idea Key points Application

Big Idea

Quoting the message: Reason says risen, end quote. — the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus stands up like a case in court, and it points to a verdict of faith, not blind belief.

The resurrection of Jesus isn't something we have to take on blind faith — it holds up to reason, evidence, and cross-examination like a legal case. Pastor Bill walks through five exhibits of evidence to show that Jesus rose from the dead, and invites listeners to stop avoiding the evidence and put their faith in Him.

Key points

1
1Exhibit A: The empty tomb is a historically proven fact.
Pastor Bill shows that Jesus' existence and burial are better documented than many ancient figures like Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great, citing Roman and Jewish historians alongside the Bible. He walks through why the tomb being empty is not disputed by serious historians, even skeptical ones, and cross-examines the guard's cover story (the disciples stole the body while they slept) to show it doesn't hold up logically.
2
2Exhibit B: The early creed and eyewitness testimony show this wasn't a slowly-grown legend.
Pastor Bill points to Paul's creed in 1 Corinthians 15, dated by skeptical scholar Gerd Ludemann to within three years of Jesus' death, and argues legends take at least two generations to form, per historian A.N. Sherwin-White. With over 500 eyewitnesses on record, he argues the resurrection claim was there from the very beginning, not added later.
3
3Exhibit C: The disciples were transformed in ways a lie could never produce.
Pastor Bill traces how scattered, fearful disciples became bold enough that 3,000 people believed after one sermon, and how Jesus' skeptical half-brother James became a follower and writer of Scripture. He notes that 10 of the 11 remaining disciples were executed and none ever recanted, arguing nobody dies for something they know is a lie.
4
4Exhibit D: The explosion of the church in the very city that opposed it.
Pastor Bill notes the church grew to roughly 100,000 people in Jerusalem within about 25 years, confirmed by Roman writers like Pliny, Suetonius, and Tacitus, growing precisely where the crucifixion and burial happened and where leaders wanted the story to die.
5
5Exhibit E: Hundreds of fulfilled prophecies written centuries before Jesus.
Pastor Bill highlights eight prophecies (like being born in Bethlehem, pierced hands and feet, and burial in a rich man's tomb) confirmed by the Dead Sea Scrolls as written long before Jesus, and cites mathematician Peter Stoner's odds of one in 10 to the 17th power for just those eight being fulfilled by one person.

I say unequivocally that the resurrection of Jesus Christ is so overwhelming that it compels acceptance by proof which leaves absolutely no room for doubt

A story from life

Pastor Bill recounts trying to get dismissed from grand jury duty as a college student in Phoenix

A story from life

Sir Lionel Luckhoo, holder of 245 consecutive acquittals, examined the resurrection evidence at age 63 and became a believer

Application

Reason says risen — so the real question is what you're going to do with that verdict.

Actually examine the evidence
Don't just dismiss or vaguely affirm the resurrection like the 78% of Americans who say they believe it but never look into it. Study the facts yourself instead of avoiding the case like a juror trying to get excused.
Stop putting faith in what's already dead
Recognize that trusting anyone or anything else to save you, whether other belief systems or your own plans, is like being buried next to someone who can't get you out.
Confess your sin and take Jesus' hand
Hand over your sin to Jesus, who died and rose again, and receive His life in exchange, following the prayer of confessing sin and trusting Him for both spiritual and eternal life.
Raise your hand and pray now
If ready to put faith in Jesus for the first time, respond in the moment by lifting a hand and praying the prayer of surrender along with Pastor Bill.

Take it into your week

Rewind AI contributed study material from the sermon transcript; church-authored wording and verified sermon quotes keep their own source. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI

Sign in to ask Rewind about this sermon

Scripture in this message

From the transcript
“In first Corinthians chapter 15, Paul is writing to this church and he's discussing the idea of the resurrection of Christ, and why it's so central and important”
From the transcript
“and why it's so central and important and for anyone who's doubting and even people that wanted to believe in Jesus may not believe in this. He said, this is why it's so important starting in verse 17”
From the transcript
“And as Matthew twenty eight six says this, he is not here. He has risen just as he said. He is not here, but he was here”
From the transcript
“And the Bible does talk about that. In the Bible in Matthew 28 talks about how Caiaphas the high priest actually met with the Roman guards who were assigned to watch the body”
From the transcript
“I wanna read a little bit more out of Ephesians Corinthians, first Corinthians 15 back in verse three. Paul says this, I passed on to you what was most important and what had also been passed on to me”
From the transcript
“Resurrection predicted, Psalm sixteen ten, a thousand BC. They didn't even believe in resurrection back then”

Rewind AI contributed study material from the sermon transcript; church-authored wording and verified sermon quotes keep their own source. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI

7-day devotional

A personal reading plan from this message — scripture, reflection, and prayer for each day.

Sign in to track your progress through this devotional.

Day 1

There is something arresting about the angel's words at the tomb: 'He isn't here! He is risen from the dead, just as he said would happen.' The invitation that follows — 'Come, see where his body was lying' — is not an appeal to feeling or tradition. It is an appeal to evidence. Look for yourself. The tomb is empty, and that emptiness is not a rumor. Roman soldiers were posted to prevent exactly the kind of story that would be convenient to invent. Jewish authorities had every motive and every resource to produce a body if one existed. They never did. What they produced instead was a cover story — that the disciples had stolen the body while trained soldiers slept. Pastor Bill pointed out that this explanation collapses the moment you press on it: sleeping soldiers cannot testify to what happened while they slept. The empty tomb does not prove the resurrection all by itself, but it does mean something happened that first Easter morning that no one on the ground could explain away. If you have ever felt that faith requires you to check your brain at the door, start here. The first witnesses were invited to come and look. That same invitation is extended to you today.

For reflection

What is one honest doubt or question you have about the resurrection that you have never fully allowed yourself to examine?

Pray

Pray for the courage to follow the evidence honestly, wherever it leads.

Day 2

One of the most powerful pieces of evidence Pastor Bill presented is hiding in plain sight inside 1 Corinthians 15. Scholars across the theological spectrum — including skeptical ones — agree that the creed Paul passes along in verses three through eight is not Paul's own composition. He received it from others, and most historians date that creed to within two or three years of the crucifixion itself. That is not enough time for legend to grow. Myths need generations to take root; this testimony was circulating while the eyewitnesses were still alive and could be questioned. Paul even names some of them. The fact that this material was already a 'received' tradition so early tells us the core claims of the resurrection were not invented decades later — they were the original message from the very beginning. This matters for you personally. When someone suggests that the resurrection story evolved over centuries like a game of telephone, you now have a historical anchor to stand on. The church did not drift toward believing Jesus rose; it was founded on that claim from day one. Your faith has roots that go all the way back to people who were there.

For reflection

How does knowing that the resurrection was proclaimed within a few years of the event — not centuries later — change the way you think about its credibility?

Pray

Pray for a deeper confidence in the historical foundation of your faith.

Day 3

Paul does not soften this verse or leave room for a comfortable middle ground: 'And if Christ has not been raised, then your faith is useless and you are still guilty of your sins.' That is a stunning thing to write, and it tells you something important about the kind of faith the New Testament actually calls for. Paul is not asking anyone to believe in a spiritual symbol or a meaningful idea. He is staking everything on a historical event — a body that was dead and then was not. Pastor Bill's whole case rests on this same foundation. The resurrection is either the best-attested miracle in the ancient world, or Christianity collapses entirely. There is no comfortable in-between. But here is what makes this verse good news rather than just pressure: Paul writes it with complete confidence, because he had already established, just verses earlier, that the risen Jesus appeared to more than 500 people at one time. The 'if' in verse 17 is a hypothetical Paul does not believe for a moment. He is saying: look at what is at stake, and look at how strong the evidence is. The fact that your faith is not useless — that it rests on something real — is worth sitting with today.

For reflection

What would it mean for your daily life if the resurrection were genuinely, historically true rather than simply a cherished belief?

Pray

Pray for a fresh sense of the weight and wonder of what the resurrection actually means for your life.

Day 4

A thousand years before Jesus walked into Jerusalem, David wrote words that the New Testament applies directly to Him: 'For you will not leave my soul among the dead or allow your holy one to rot in the grave.' Pastor Bill made a striking point about this kind of prophecy. The Dead Sea Scrolls have given us manuscripts of Isaiah and the Psalms that predate Jesus by a century or more, which means no one can argue the prophecies were written after the fact to fit the story. They were already there, waiting. Crucifixion was not even a known method of execution when Psalm 22 described pierced hands and feet. The mathematical odds of one person fulfilling even a fraction of the 300-plus Messianic prophecies by chance are, as Pastor Bill noted, effectively zero. What this means for your faith is that God has been pointing toward Jesus for a very long time. The resurrection was not a surprise ending — it was the destination the whole Old Testament was moving toward. When you read your Bible, you are reading one story that holds together across centuries, cultures, and authors, all arriving at an empty tomb.

For reflection

Does knowing that the resurrection was foretold centuries in advance change how you read the Old Testament? What might you want to explore further?

Pray

Pray for a growing sense of the unity and trustworthiness of the whole Bible.

Day 5

Related passage

Peter and John, standing before the same religious authorities who had handed Jesus over to be killed, say something remarkable: 'Do you think God wants us to obey you rather than him? We cannot stop telling about everything we have seen and heard.' These are not the same men who hid behind locked doors on the night of the arrest. Something happened between that locked room and this courtroom — and Pastor Bill's point is that what happened is the only explanation that actually fits. People do not die brutal deaths to protect a story they know is a lie. The disciples had nothing to gain by fabricating the resurrection. They lost homes, status, and eventually their lives. But people absolutely will die for something they genuinely witnessed and cannot bring themselves to deny. The transformation of the disciples is not a side note in the resurrection case — it is some of the most compelling human evidence on the table. When you feel hesitant to speak about your faith, it is worth remembering that the first people to do so had far more to lose than you do. Their courage was not manufactured — it was the natural overflow of having seen something they could not unsee.

For reflection

What is one area of your life where you have stayed quieter about your faith than you might want to be? What is the fear underneath that silence?

Pray

Pray for the kind of quiet courage that comes from conviction, not performance.

Day 6

Related passage

Three thousand people were baptized in a single day — in Jerusalem, the very city where Jesus had been publicly executed weeks before. Pastor Bill highlighted this as one of the most striking data points in the entire case. If the resurrection were a fabrication, Jerusalem was the worst possible place to launch it. The tomb was nearby. The soldiers who guarded it were nearby. The witnesses to the crucifixion were nearby. The authorities who wanted the movement stopped were very much nearby and very much motivated. And yet the church did not begin somewhere safe and quiet — it ignited at the center of the storm. Within 25 years, estimates suggest the number of believers in and around Jerusalem had grown to roughly 100,000. Roman historians outside the Christian tradition noted the movement's extraordinary spread. You cannot explain that kind of growth in that particular location with a lie that anyone could have unraveled by walking to the tomb. The explosive growth of the early church is not just a feel-good origin story — it is a piece of historical evidence. The people who were closest to the events, with the most reason to be skeptical, became the first and most committed believers.

For reflection

How does the geographic and historical context of the early church's growth shape the way you think about the credibility of the resurrection?

Pray

Pray for a renewed sense of what it means to be part of a community built on this foundation.

Day 7

All week you have sat with the evidence — the empty tomb, the early creed, the eyewitnesses, the transformed disciples, the explosive church, the ancient prophecies. Pastor Bill's closing challenge was not to admire the case but to render a verdict and then decide what to do with it. That is where every honest inquiry eventually arrives. Evidence does not stay neutral forever; at some point it asks something of you. If you are still working through doubt, that is not a failure — it is the beginning of the kind of honest searching that this sermon invited. Keep going. If you have believed for a long time but have sometimes felt your faith was more emotional than grounded, this week may have given you something solid to stand on. And if this week has brought you to a place where you are ready to respond — to confess that you have gone your own way and to place your trust in the only one who is not still in His grave — that step is available to you right now, simply and directly. As Pastor Bill put it, you hand Him your sin and take His hand for your life. That is what it means to be risen with Him. Whatever your next step is, do not sit with it alone. Bring it to someone at Rock Point who can walk with you.

For reflection

Having followed the evidence through this week, what is the one thing you most need to do in response — and who in your life can you tell about it?

Pray

Pray for the clarity and honesty to act on what you now believe to be true.

Rewind AI contributed study material from the sermon transcript; church-authored wording and verified sermon quotes keep their own source. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI

Small-group discussion guide

For leading a group conversation about this message.

Open

One of the boldest claims in history is that a man rose from the dead — and this message argues that claim is not a matter of blind faith but of hard evidence. Before we jump into questions, take a moment to think about which of the five 'exhibits' Pastor Bill walked through landed most freshly for you.

Discussion questions

1
Pastor Bill pointed out that neither the Romans nor the Jewish leaders ever produced a body, and that the 'disciples stole it' story collapses under basic cross-examination. What details of that argument did the group find most compelling — or most worth pushing back on?
2
In 1 Corinthians 15:3–8, Paul cites a creed that Pastor Bill dated to within three years of the crucifixion, and references more than 515 eyewitnesses — many of whom were still alive when Paul wrote. Why would the timing of that creed, and the fact that those witnesses could still be questioned, matter to the case Pastor Bill was building?
3
Pastor Bill described the disciples going from hiding behind locked doors to proclaiming the resurrection openly — and dying for it without anyone recanting. What does that transformation suggest about what those men actually believed they had seen?
4
The church grew to roughly 100,000 believers in Jerusalem — the very city where the crucifixion happened — within about 25 years, a fact Pastor Bill noted was confirmed even by Roman historians. Why would the location of that growth matter as a piece of evidence?
5
Pastor Bill pointed to Psalm 16:10 and the broader pattern of 300-plus Old Testament prophecies as part of the case, noting that the Dead Sea Scrolls establish those texts predate Jesus' birth. How does fulfilled prophecy function differently from the other historical exhibits he presented — and how do the two kinds of evidence work together?
6
Pastor Bill closed by saying the evidence has been presented and the only remaining question is what a person does with it. For people who already follow Jesus but have felt uncertain about the historical grounding of their faith, how might the case laid out in this message change the way we talk about what we believe — and why we believe it?

Pray together

Gratitude that faith in the risen Jesus is anchored in truth — and openness for each person to respond to that truth in whatever next step is in front of them

Rewind AI contributed study material from the sermon transcript; church-authored wording and verified sermon quotes keep their own source. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI

Sign in to save this message.

Go deeper

Continue the series

Evidence of Eternity

Week 2 · 6 messages

Where these passages are preached

1 Corinthians 15 Matthew 28 Psalm 16

Explore related topics

Apologetics Eyewitness Testimony Historical Evidence Resurrection of Jesus The Risen Lord

Related sermons

Burdens & Blessings | Week 2 | Sermon
Pastor Bill Bush · Nov 25, 2024
Shares scripture
Weekday Warrior | Week 3
Pastor Chris Hilken · Jul 20, 2026
Shares scripture
Easter at Rock Point 2026
Pastor Bill Bush · Apr 5, 2026
Shares scripture
True Grit | Week 3 | Full Service
Pastor Rocky High · Mar 9, 2026
Shares scripture
Basics | Week 5 | Message
Pastor Nolan Tjaden · Oct 13, 2025
Shares scripture
Distorted | Week 5 | Full Service
Pastor Caleb McMains · Jul 9, 2025
Shares scripture

Powered by Rewind · make your church's Rewind →